What makes a man a man? Wow, is that a loaded question. It’s a question I’ve been exploring for many years now. In that search, I’ve come to a few basic conclusions.
- Gender is a human-made social construct, different than the sexual classification of human beings based on the reproductive organs they are born with. In essence, gender and all of its verbiage (eg. man or woman) are fluid and largely self-prescribed, influenced heavily by social stereotypical classifications. Whether you were born with male or female (or both) reproductive organs are a static classification.
- Because gender is based on societal definitions and society changes, there is no definitive set of criteria to answer the question of what makes a man a man. At best, we have grossly ambiguous and unwieldy ideas of what makes a man a man and a woman a woman.
- Human beings who lean towards more definitive, concrete thought processes often will struggle with the ambiguity associated with some societal constructs like gender.
- I’ve discovered that the essence of being a man is not exclusive to being masculine. It is universal and applies across all humankind.
Perhaps this would be a good time to point out that I am not an expert anything relevant to the world. These are my conclusions and I own them. I also own that I have been wrong about a lot of things in life. Facts have been known to change my mind, and I’m certainly not done learning in this life. These are my observations and you’re more than welcome to disagree with them. You’re more than welcome to help me learn and keep me on my toes.
With that admonition, let me expand just a bit on my bulleted observations above. I identify as a man. I am a male. I am confident that there are both biological and societal influences that factor in my self-identification as a man. Others classify me as a man as well, as I have presented myself this way in the world.
Though I am a man, I don’t like or embrace everything society has prescribed as masculine stereotypes. While I love sports and barbequing meat, you won’t catch me working on a car or framing a new addition to my house. I have the physical finesse of a giant lumberjack, relying on brute force as a means to an end, yet I thoroughly enjoy the theater. All of these attributes are integral to what makes me uniquely me, yet they have a loose relationship with my identification as a man. Just because I enjoy the scent of fine leather, the warmth of dark mahogany woods and other masculine accouterments doesn’t make me a man. In fact, all of the attributes I’ve described could just as easily be shared by a 10-year-old boy or girl.
All of this has led me to the conclusion that what makes a man a man (or a woman a woman) has far more to do with maturity and fulfilling social responsibilities than it does with the identification with masculine attributes. To be a man (or a woman), one must be accountable to each other and must strive for alignment between their words and their actions. They must care for the people in their lives and be good stewards of the world around them. These attributes are neither masculine nor feminine. They are merely human.
I am not ashamed of my masculinity. In fact, I embrace it. I’m comfortable with it, even if I don’t embrace all of the attributes generally classified as masculine. I also appreciate my traits that society has classified as feminine in nature. My ability to be a nurturer or to enjoy a classic Jane Austen novel is not in conflict with my identity as a man. It is a compliment to it. I’ll write about masculinity as the dark side that can accompany some of those attributes. But these attributes have little to do with me being a man.
These are my observations as I enjoy my 47th trip around this sun. As I continue to evolve and learn, I can predict that my observations in the future will also evolve. That is what learning is of course. Maybe with your help, we can learn together. Maybe some of these words will resonate with you. Maybe grand and important dialogue will come as a result of this exploration together.